Everybody loves a good flood

MUMBAI’S MOVIE mulgis used to leave us thirsty. Five years ago, their metropolis joined them in hatching a parching plot.

Blame it on climate change or whimsical weather gods, India’s commercial – and film? – capital on the Arabian seacoast began hijacking Assam’s monsoon in 2006. As the Americans would say colloquially, varsha hritu was all wet since (barring 2008).

Last (2009) monsoon was no different. Mumbai waded as Assam waited to be wet enough. So did the other northeastern states.

The unusual dry run precluded annual displacement for an average 5,000,000 people across Assam’s floodplains. But it left some government employees heartbroken; their bank balance was directly proportional to the floodwater level.

What ‘rain cuts’ and ‘silt clearance’ are for Irrigation Department officials across India, flood and erosion are for their counterparts in Assam’s Water Resources (formerly Flood Control) Department.

God, I thought, knew best how deep or wide raindrops cut the sides of earthen canals or how thick the silt is under water. I was wrong; most Irrigation officials know better, making money for filling up/repairing the rain cuts and clearing silt by the fictitious inch.

At least the Irrigation chaps don’t cash in on other people’s miseries. More often than not, Water Resources bosses spend a fortune to create a scenario necessitating the ‘control’ of floods. If things, except for their cuts from projects, invariably get out of control, there’s a readymade excuse: it is impossible to control nature’s fury.

And when nature leaks like mad, how can you expect low-cost measures to save 3,160,000 hectares of land in Assam – this is 9.4 per cent of India’s total flood-prone area, says National Flood Commission – from inundation?

Even thinking low-cost is a sin. Members of the outlawed United Liberation Front of Asom (Ulfa), we are told, killed social activist Sanjoy Ghosh for daring to come up with an anti-erosion project (in Majuli Island) that cost less than one-thousandth of Rs 20 million the erstwhile Flood Control would have spent.

If you can’t fathom the Ulfa-FC connection, Google National Investigation Agency, North Cachar Hills, diversion of government funds and Dima Halam Daogah (Jewel), a tribe-specific militant outfit.

According to Assam Chief Minister Tarun Gogoi, erosion is a bigger problem than floods – maybe because the government receives far less money to check erosion than control floods.

Statistics reveal that in 2002, Assam incurred a loss of Rs 6,390 million owing to floods and erosion. Subsequently, the government demanded Central aid from New Delhi for flood damage repair and anti-erosion. The money given did not match the Rs 1,610 million received after the devastating 1988 floods.

In 1998, Assam received Rs 600 million as Central aid compared to Rs 3,000 million given to the northern Indian state of Uttar Pradesh. Both states suffered equally, but New Delhi apparently felt Assam’s crisis was less important.

The Assam government and various organizations have been demanding National Disaster status for the annual floods. New Delhi seems reluctant to give the tag. Maybe because it thinks floods in Assam aren’t anything new, or because Assam isn’t ‘mainstream’, or because National Disaster would entail fatter funds for Water Resources officials to capitalize on a ‘national scale’.

Whether or not Assam’s drenching disaster is national enough, the smiles are back on the faces of Water Resources officials. Why not? It isn’t monsoon yet, and Assam is reeling under water. After years, pre-monsoon showers have showered enough misery on poor villagers to make money from.

P Sainath had a decade ago written the masterly Everybody Loves a Good Drought. He, obviously, had no interest in flood-prone areas.


About rahconteur

A mid-career journalist who's worked horizontally across India - from Arunachal Pradesh to Gujarat
This entry was posted in Bric-a-brac. Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Everybody loves a good flood

  1. lakshman says:

    Why Sainath ignored floods can best be explained by our South Indian mind set that is for ever crying for water. You would perhaps appreciate it more if you were a Madrasi or Chennaite.

    I remember as a reporter on duty for the first day with the Hindu in Delhi I had dismissed a water shortage story in two paras.

    whereupon I got a stinker calling for an indepth story as long in wordage as possible.

    I guess no amount of human intervention can solve the problem for us in India. It has to be prayers to a plethora of gods and goddesses that might still do the trick.

    Or else, it is our Kharma (fate in Telugu) to suffer the problems of poverty and plenty of water, and almost every other human and natural resources.

    Your fan and student.

    Waiting nervously for the result — Pappu pass ho gaya ki nahin ???

  2. rahconteur says:

    I am sure Sainath, if he sees this post or anything similar anywhere else, will be keen to do a wet sequel.

    And, Pappu abhi tak pass nahin hua hai.

  3. ketaki says:

    our problems are now compounded by the complete abdication of responsibility of the politicians about the city’s plight….they are saying we should learn to live with floods and waterlogging!!!
    so few Water Resource Dept and Irrigation Dept officials and politicians get rich and the rest of the tax paying citizens drown in sewage and floodwaters….

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s